Earlier this week, I had the opportunity to extensively test the content management system Pligg. If you’re looking for a “ratings” type of website — a website devoted exclusively to a ratings system — then Pligg might be for you. Unfortunately, Pligg is still in a “beta” stage and not quite ready for prime time. If you’re familiar with the WordPress or Joomla frameworks (for example), then you will probably be frustrated with Pligg.
WordPress has benefitted from a longer development cycle and a usage that is nearly ubiquitous among the blogging community. And Pligg is less of a blog than a content management system. With Pligg, you have the opportunity to plug in different modules to customize Pligg to your liking, and you also can incorporate different skins to alter the design of Pligg.
There are but a few skins available for Pligg, and as with most content management systems, the “design” changes really have more to do with color and column width variables than true design options. One thinks of the over 1500 public (free) themes available for WordPress, plus the dozens of premium and “developer” grade themes available… Not to mention monster themes like our personal favorite, Thesis, and, well, it’s a pale comparison. Pardon our lack of diplomacy, but Pligg is the poor second cousin who arrived late for dinner, and has a lot of growing up to do. No offense to the Pligg community, because I think some day Pligg will truly grow up to be someone.
With regard to a ratings type of website, you can get ratings plugins for WordPress that provide ratings on posts and stories. And there are numerous examples of adapting the WordPress theme to a content management system, and those have their place as well as their pro’s and con’s… However, if you truly need a content management system — something where you pull data from other sources and populate it into your website — that database-driven aspect of serving data might be (eventually) better served in Pligg.
This reviewer sees some promise with Pligg. If you were to download Pligg to test drive, bear in mind that the installation is not difficult with an experienced web developer, but it is more cumbersome and multi-stepped than, say, a WordPress installation via Fantastico in cPanel. If you can follow the detailed instructions and know how to change file permissions on your server, then you should have no problem. One tip — READ THE README file. It’s crucial to your well being as a Pligg installer. Lol
One wonders why there are not more skins available for Pligg, as it seems fairly straightforward to customize. It is (like WordPress) PHP-based, so it’s a system that’s open source and ready to be developed, and will likely be so once it catches on amongst developers and users.
Do I ever see Pligg becoming as widespread as WordPress? Likely not. The singular benefits of Pligg focus on a fairly narrow definition for website need. Pligg is for that niche of web developer and website owner who strictly needs a ratings-based content management system. At least from the time I spent taking it apart, that’s what I see in its present form.
Each technology and platform fills a purpose, and there is no dragon slayer out there that is the end-all be-all of web platforms. One client might truly benefit from Pligg, another from WordPress, while a third might need a Flash website. This is where consulting with a professional web developer can save you months of development time and thousands of dollars in wasted expense and lost revenue. You owe it to yourself to find a developer who has a wide breadth of experience and can advise you on the best strategy to implement for your business — a developer like Kinetics Web Pro. Woops, sorry for the shameless plug.
I’ll continue to monitor Pligg’s development and report back on the improvements as they occur. Bottom line: is Pligg the next best thing? Uh… no.
Technorati Tags: CMS, Content Managment System, Joomla, Pligg, Web Design, Wordpress